Elon Musk is certainly one of the best-known high-net-worth individuals in the world, and he has recently been under heat from various sources, including the SEC. Musk recently made headlines for agreeing on a settlement with the SEC following a tweet in early August. In addition to the interest in the settlement from a purely financial and business perspective, many are curious about the tax implications regarding the SEC settlement, both for Musk himself and for his company, Tesla.
Leading to the Settlement
The story regarding the SEC settlement begins in early August when Elon Musk made a tweet about potentially taking Tesla private. The SEC was far from pleased with this tweet and began an investigation. During the time, Musk remained in the headlines for other reasons as well. Finally, in late September, the SEC filed an action against Elon Musk, indicating that he misled investors about a potential buyout. Just a few days following this filing, Musk as well as Tesla had already settled with the SEC.
The Settlement Itself
As part of the settlement with the SEC, Tesla and Elon Musk will pay hefty fines, $40 million in total, and make various concessions. Although Musk is able to remain the CEO of Tesla, he must step down as the company’s chairman for a minimum of three years. In return, the SEC will end its suit. The total fine of $40 million is divided equally between Musk and Tesla, with each entity paying $20 million. While this fine seems high to the average person, it is nothing for high-net-worth individuals like Musk. After all, his fortune is estimated at $20 billion. Tesla is valued at about $2.2 billion, so the company will not hurt following this settlement either.
The Tax Questions
While all of the above is accepted fact, there are questions regarding the tax implications regarding the settlement. Can Musk and Tesla write off this settlement to pay a low tax? This question was initially fueled by the fact that the SEC did not indicate either way in its statement. It is very possible that tax write-offs will not be prohibited since the SEC indicated that the penalties of $40 million will be distributed among the harmed investors in a process that is court-approved.
Taxes and Fines
Some of the debate regarding the tax implications of the settlement has been alleviated upon discovery of a court filing where Tesla agreed not to claim a tax deduction. This means that there will be no corporate tax deduction for $20 million of the fine, but what about Musk’s portion? It’s complicated since tax codes prohibit the deduction of fines and penalties that are paid to the government due to legal violations. Despite this, there are numerous exceptions, making it easy for those with knowledge and money to get around the prohibition. Although Tesla explicitly agreed not to file for one of these exceptions and file a deduction, it remains to be seen whether Elon Musk will qualify for one. Experts are keeping a close eye on this high-net-worth individual and his taxes.
Did you find this article useful?
Subscribe to our newsletter for more!