Ireland’s Tax Haven Status Is Causing Controversy
Most countries do not want to be labeled as tax havens since this can come with criticism and possible penalties from other countries. At the same time, however, having the status as a tax haven brings in more business to a country as companies and high-net-worth individuals will move their assets there to reduce their tax bills. Ireland is just one of the countries currently facing criticism and labeling as a tax haven.
The Recent Report Highlighting the Issues
For several years, Ireland has been commonly included in lists of tax havens, or at least possible tax havens. It is no secret that many multinational corporations take advantage of the low tax rates in Ireland by basing headquarters and some operations there. The recent resurgence of the debate regarding Ireland and tax havens come from a new report that the European Parliament has accepted.
This report criticized Ireland for acting like a tax haven. It included additional criticism for the country’s role in blocking proposals for taxes on digital services from the EU Council. The report had similar criticism for Denmark, Finland, and Sweden as well.
Tax Loopholes and Other Criticisms
The report also strongly backed the European Commission’s initiatives that will close various tax loopholes. At the same time, it outlined criticism for the fact that the reforms are taking place at the level of the EU Council.
It additionally raised questions regarding the economic activity levels by multinational corporations in Ireland as it relates to foreign direct investment. This particular criticism also applied to six other EU Member States: Belgium, the Netherlands, Cyprus, Luxembourg, Hungary, and Malta.
Other Details From the Report
In addition to the above criticism for Ireland and a handful of other countries, the report also recommended removing the ability of governments to use a veto in the European Council for blocking tax reforms. Instead, the report calls for adjustments to the current requirement for unanimity. This would only apply in situations where the differences in provisions in Member States “distorts” competition conditions within the internal market.
Suggestions From the Report
Based on the conclusions and details in the report, it suggests taking robust action against money laundering. It even goes so far as to name several banks connected to Russian money laundering. It further calls for funding that will support whistleblowers and investigative journalism. The report also suggests the creation of a financial police force for Europe, an anti-money-laundering watchdog, and a financial intelligence unit for the EU.
Ireland’s Take on Its Tax Haven Designation
For years, Ireland has been up-front about its objections to being labeled as a tax haven. In fact, the country has also taken steps relatively recently to fight off this label. This includes eliminating and otherwise reforming loopholes related to taxes.
The report bringing the controversy regarding Ireland as a tax haven back into the spotlight is still relatively recent. As such, more time is needed to see how this report affects the actions of Ireland as well as those of the EU. For now, high-net-worth individuals and businesses will likely continue to use the country for its tax loopholes, but this may have to change in the future if regulations change.
Sources:
https://www.rte.ie/news/business/2019/0326/1038812-ireland-european-report/
https://www.tasc.ie/blog/2019/04/05/is-ireland-a-tax-haven/
Did you find this article useful?
Subscribe to our newsletter for more!